Carter Law Group
  • Home
  • Let’s Meet
    • Amy Carter, Managing Shareholder
    • Heather Davis, Partner & Chief Operating Officer
    • Hon. Erin Nowell, Of Counsel
    • Kassi Yukevich, Senior Attorney
    • Tracy Pace, Paralegal
    • Kyndal Hetmer, Paralegal
    • TaNia Robinson, Intake Specialist
    • Ethan Green, Legal Technology and Automation Assistant
  • Areas of Expertise
    • Personal Injury
      • Product Liability
      • Premises Liability
      • Sexual Assault
      • Sex Trafficking
      • Sex Crimes by Massage Therapists
      • Sexual Crimes on Campus and in Campus Organizations
      • Sexual Crimes in Organized Sports
      • Sex Crimes in Religious Organizations
      • Sexual Abuse
    • Employment Discrimination
      • Age Discrimination
      • Disability Discrimination
      • Gender Discrimination
      • LGTBQIA+ Discrimination
      • National Origin Discrimination
      • Racial Discrimination
      • Religious Discrimination
      • Sexual Harassment
  • Results
  • Testimonials
  • Community Involvement
  • Education and Resources
    • Products Liability
    • Product Recalls
    • Sexual Assault
    • Silicosis
    • The Legal Process 101
    • Employment Discrimination
    • Areas Served
      • Collin County
        • Allen
        • Plano
        • Frisco
        • Addison
        • Carrollton
        • The Colony
      • Dallas County
        • Dallas
        • Irving
        • Mesquite
        • Richardson
        • Farmers Branch
        • Garland
        • Carrollton
        • Addison
        • Bishop Arts District
        • Oak Cliff
        • Kessler
        • Trinity Groves
        • Cockrell Hill
        • Coppell
        • Rowlett
      • Grayson County
        • Denison
        • Sherman
      • Johnson County
        • Burleson
        • Cleburne
      • Tarrant County
        • Fort Worth
        • Arlington
        • Southlake
        • Grapevine
        • Mid-Cities
      • Kaufman County
      • Parker County
  • Fight Like A Mother: The Blog
    • Press
  • Contact Us
    • Discrimination Intake Questionnaire
  • Menu Menu
Empty upper level of a concrete parking garage in warm afternoon light
Amy Carter

Assaulted in a Parking Lot or Garage? When You Can Sue for Negligent Security in Texas

November 19, 2026/in Sexual Assault/by Amy Carter

We believe you. If you were attacked in a parking lot or garage in Texas, the person who did it may not be the only one responsible. The company that owns or runs the lot or garage can be sued too, if it knew, or should have known, that people were in danger there and didn’t take reasonable steps to protect them.

Lawyers call this a negligent security claim. It’s a type of premises liability case, which is a lawsuit against the company responsible for keeping a property safe. At Carter Law Group, we bring these cases for sexual assault survivors, because everyone who made an assault possible should answer for it, not only the attacker. If you were assaulted in the parking garage at your hospital, for example, that’s a premises case.

Texas courts turn down many of these claims, often for one of three reasons: the company sued didn’t actually control the lot or garage, nothing like the attack had happened there before, or there was no evidence of what better security would have cost.

Two things can’t wait, even while you’re still deciding whether to sue. One is the owner’s camera footage, which is often recorded over automatically. The other, after a sexual assault, is a forensic exam. Go as soon as you can, ideally within five days, though a later exam can still be possible. If you’re reading this for someone you love, both are things you can help with now. What to do now explains each one, along with what else to save.

Isn’t the attacker the only one responsible?

A company that runs a parking lot or garage can share responsibility for an attack there, even though someone else committed it. The rule in Texas is that property owners generally don’t have to protect people from crimes other people commit (UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie). The exception is the company in control of the property. If it knows, or should know, that the people it invites there face a serious risk of crime, it has to take reasonable steps to protect them (Lefmark Management Co. v. Old).

The attacker still carries a share of the blame. In a Texas lawsuit, the jury decides what percentage of the responsibility belongs to each person involved: the company you sue, the attacker, and sometimes you (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33). The company generally pays only its own percentage of your damages, not the attacker’s. It can ask the court to include the attacker in that split, which lowers its own share.

We’ve written more generally about whether you can sue a property owner for a crime and about premises liability lawsuits for sexual assault survivors.

Who can you sue after a parking lot or garage assault?

You can sue a company that controlled the lot or garage when you were attacked, even if it didn’t own the property. More than one company can have control, such as the owner and a company that leases or runs the lot (Watanabe v. Summit Path Partners). Depending on the property, those can include:

  • the owner
  • a property management company that runs it for the owner
  • a parking company that operates it
  • the store, hotel, hospital or apartment complex whose customers, guests, patients or tenants park there, if it runs the parking

Getting this right matters. In one Texas Supreme Court case, the person who sued lost because the management company they sued didn’t own, manage or control the shopping center when the crime happened (Lefmark).

A security company hired to guard or patrol the lot can sometimes be responsible too, but only for what its contract made it responsible for. In a 2022 Houston case, a woman attacked in a shopping center parking lot lost her claim against the guard company, because the company didn’t control the property and owed no duty beyond its contract (Hicks v. G4S Secure Solutions).

If the attack happened in a bar’s parking lot and the bar overserved alcohol beforehand, the bar may be responsible as well. That’s a separate kind of claim, which we explain on our page about sexual assault cases against bars.

What you have to prove in a Texas negligent security case

Once you know which company to sue, your case has to answer four questions:

  1. Was the attack foreseeable? Did the company know, or should it have known, that an attack like this was a real risk there?
  2. Was the risk serious enough to call for more security? The danger has to outweigh what it would have cost the company to reduce it, for example by adding lights, fixing a gate or hiring a guard.
  3. Did the company fall short? Its security has to have been less than that risk called for.
  4. Did that failure help cause the assault? The gap in security has to be one of the reasons the assault happened.

Infographic of the four questions a negligent security case must answer: foreseeability, risk, falling short and cause

Evidence of earlier crimes answers the first question, but the second needs its own proof. In a 2017 case, the Texas Supreme Court ruled against a person shot at an apartment complex because they offered no evidence of what it would have taken the complex to prevent a crime like that one (UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie).

Do there have to be other crimes there before mine?

In most cases, a claim needs earlier crimes on or near the property to show the attack was foreseeable. Texas courts look at five things about those crimes, which come from a 1998 Texas Supreme Court case, Timberwalk Apartments v. Cain:

  • Where: whether they happened on the property or near it
  • When: how recently they happened
  • How often: how many there were over time
  • How similar: how much they resembled what happened to you
  • Who knew: whether they were publicized in a way that shows the owner knew, or should have known, about them

Infographic: Texas courts weigh earlier crimes by where, when, how often, how similar and who knew, all together

Courts look at all five together. The more the earlier crimes resemble yours, the fewer of them you need. They don’t have to match your attack exactly, because the owner only has to have been able to foresee the general kind of danger.

When there’s no history at all, a claim is very hard. Texas courts have made a narrow exception where the owner’s staff actually knew violence was about to happen, as with a brawl building in a resort’s bar (Del Lago Partners v. Smith).

What if there were break-ins or robberies there, but never an assault?

It depends on how much those crimes resemble what happened to you. Three Texas cases show how courts have weighed it:

  • Vague reports and nonviolent crimes weren’t enough. A woman abducted from a San Antonio parking lot won at trial and lost on appeal. The evidence of earlier crimes was vague, was mostly about nonviolent crime, and none of it could be tied to the lot (Allright San Antonio Parking v. Kendrick).
  • Robberies weren’t enough for a killing. A shopping center had ten robberies in 23 months, none with a weapon fired and none leaving anyone seriously hurt. When a man was shot and killed as he left its movie theater for his car, the Texas Supreme Court held the killing was too different from those robberies to be foreseeable (Trammell Crow Central Texas v. Gutierrez).
  • Repeated violence was enough to go forward. A nightclub had drawn more than twenty police calls in a year, fourteen of them involving violence. According to a security expert, the club failed to provide video surveillance of its parking lot and failed to have outside security patrol it. A court let a claim over a shooting in that lot go forward (Garcia v. Fifth Club).

So car break-ins alone are unlikely to support a claim over an assault. Earlier robberies, assaults or other violence against people at or near the lot bring you closer, depending on how much they resemble your attack.

What counts as negligent security in a parking lot or garage?

Reasonable security depends on the risk at each property. In a lot or garage, negligent security can mean failures in any of these:

  • Lighting. A U.S. Department of Justice research brief calls lighting “the most important security feature in a parking facility” (National Institute of Justice). That includes burned-out lights, dark corners and unlit stairwells.
  • Cameras. Whether there were any, whether they worked, and whether they covered the spot where you were attacked.
  • Gates, doors and locks. Whether gates closed, whether stairwell and pedestrian doors locked, and whether anyone kept track of who came in, with a ticket at the entrance or an attendant at the exit.
  • Patrols and guards. Whether anyone patrolled, how often, and whether coverage stopped before the hours when the risk was highest.
  • Emergency phones and call buttons. Whether they existed, whether they worked, and whether you could have reached one.
  • Stairwells and elevators. Enclosed stairwells and elevator lobbies hide whoever is inside from people passing by, which is why the same federal brief recommends making them as open as building codes allow.
  • Warnings. Whether the owner told people when security ended. In a 1986 Houston case, a jury held a garage operator liable for a robbery partly because customers weren’t warned that no one was on duty between 5:30 p.m., when the attendant left, and 8 p.m. (Allright, Inc. v. Pearson).

Illustration of a parking garage labeling lighting, cameras, gates, guards, call buttons, stairwells and warnings

If the company broke its own security rules, that helps only after you’ve shown the attack was foreseeable. A Texas appeals court said in 2024 that a company’s internal policies don’t create a legal duty that wouldn’t otherwise exist (Walmart Stores Texas v. Lacy).

Does it matter whether you were a customer, a tenant, or just parking there?

The company’s duty to protect people from crime covers people who are there on business that benefits both them and the owner. That includes customers, patients, hotel guests, tenants and people who pay to park. The law calls them invitees (Austin v. Kroger Texas), and Texas courts have treated both a monthly parker in a garage and a customer of a surface lot that way.

If you were just passing through, or there for a reason that had nothing to do with the owner’s business, the owner may owe you much less, which makes a claim harder (Catholic Diocese of El Paso v. Porter). Your status depends on the facts, so it’s worth asking a lawyer. Our premises liability page explains the categories the law uses for visitors.

Assaulted in the parking garage at work

If you were assaulted in a parking garage at work, you may have a negligent security claim against the company that controls the garage, if that company isn’t your employer. The garage might belong to a landlord or a parking company that serves the whole building, and that company can be sued like any other owner. Whether you can also sue your employer depends on separate rules, including workers’ compensation. Our workplace sexual assault page covers claims after an assault at work, including one in a workplace parking lot.

Can I sue if the attacker was never caught?

You can sue the company that ran the lot or garage even if the person who attacked you was never caught. A civil claim doesn’t need a police report, an arrest or a conviction, as we explain on our page about civil sexual assault claims. It also has a lower standard of proof. A criminal case needs proof beyond a reasonable doubt, but you win a civil case by showing your version is more likely true than not (OER Texas).

The company can still ask the court to give the unknown attacker a share of the responsibility, under the name “John Doe” or “Jane Doe” (Section 33.004). That lowers the company’s share, but your case goes on.

What if I was walking alone at night, or had been drinking?

Walking to your car alone, at night, or after a drink doesn’t make an assault your fault. We don’t need you to convince us of what happened, or to explain why you were there, before we’ll talk with you about it.

The company may still argue that you were partly responsible, and the jury can give you a percentage of the responsibility along with the company and the attacker. As long as your share is 50 percent or less, you can still recover, reduced by your percentage. Only if the jury puts your share above 50 percent do you recover nothing (Section 33.001). Don’t let this worry keep you from asking whether you have a case.

How long do you have to file a lawsuit?

In Texas, plan on two years to file a lawsuit against the company that ran the lot or garage. Some survivors have longer, and a government owner has to get notice much sooner:

Your situation Deadline
An adult hurt in a robbery, beating, stabbing, kidnapping or other attack, including groping or other sexual contact not described in the next row Two years to file a lawsuit (Section 16.003)
An adult who was sexually assaulted, meaning sexual penetration without consent, or contact between one person’s sexual organ and another’s mouth, anus or sexual organ without consent. The same period applies to trafficking and compelling prostitution Five years against the attacker (Section 16.0045(b)). Against the lot or garage owner, the law isn’t clear, so plan on two years
The survivor was under 18 Longer deadlines apply, and the clock doesn’t start until the survivor turns 18. Ask a lawyer early
A city, county or other government body owns the lot or garage Notice to the government within six months of the assault, describing the injury, when and where it happened, and what happened (Section 101.101). A city’s charter can set a shorter period (Texas Municipal League). The lawsuit deadline still applies too

A lawyer should confirm which of these applies to you. For a government owner, that includes checking the city’s charter for a shorter notice period. It also includes whether formal notice can be skipped. That happens only if the government already knew about your injury and knew that the fault you’re claiming against it played a part.

What if a city or other government body owns the lot or garage?

A government owner is harder to sue than a private company, even if the six-month notice goes out on time. Claims against Texas government bodies go through the Texas Tort Claims Act, which allows lawsuits only in limited situations. The Act doesn’t cover a claim that the government failed to provide police protection (Section 101.055(3)).

The Act also leaves out claims “arising out of assault, battery, false imprisonment, or any other intentional tort” (Section 101.057), but that exclusion is narrower than it sounds. The Texas Supreme Court has held that it doesn’t block a claim about the government’s own carelessness when someone else did the attacking. In that case, a student was raped in her dormitory room by an intruder who came in through a door with a broken lock the university never fixed, and the exclusion didn’t bar her claims (Delaney v. University of Houston).

Whether a claim against a public owner can go forward depends on the facts. City garages, county hospitals and public universities are all government owners, so if one of them owns the place where you were attacked, talk to a lawyer early, well inside those six months.

What to do now, and what to save

If you were sexually assaulted and need to talk to someone right now, the RAINN National Sexual Assault Hotline is free, confidential and open 24/7 at 800.656.HOPE (4673). The Texas Association Against Sexual Assault has a locator for crisis centers near you. Then, as you’re able:

  • Get medical care, and a forensic exam if you want one, as soon as you can. Hospitals and other providers that treat sexual assault survivors have to do the exam for an adult who arrives within 120 hours (five days) and agrees to it. Other providers have to refer you to one that does. After 120 hours, an exam can still be possible with a referral, and a child can be examined at any time. You don’t have to report to the police or help with a prosecution to get the exam, and you can’t be made to pay for the evidence-collection part of the exam or the evidence kit. If you get the exam without reporting, the evidence is held for up to five years, so you have time to decide about the police (Tex. Code Crim. Proc. ch. 56A).
  • Ask the owner, in writing, to keep the video before it’s recorded over. The owner’s legal duty to keep evidence starts only when it knows, or should know, that there’s a substantial chance of a claim (Petroleum Solutions v. Head). A written request, sent quickly, tells the owner that. A lawyer can send the request for you. Our post on how security cameras affect premises liability claims explains more about camera footage as evidence.
  • Photograph the scene, if you feel safe going back or someone you trust can go for you. Get the lights that are out, the dark corners and stairwells, cameras that are missing, broken or pointed away, gates or doors that don’t close or lock, and any signs about security. If you can, take the photos at the same time of day as the attack, because lighting changes.
  • Keep proof of why you were there. A parking ticket or receipt, a gate card, a store receipt, a hotel bill or an appointment record shows you were there as a customer, guest, patient or tenant.
  • Write down what you remember. Note the lighting, the cameras, whether a guard or attendant was around, whether anyone answered when you called for help, and who saw what happened. It’s fine if it comes back in pieces.
  • Don’t sign anything or give a recorded statement to the owner or its insurance company until you’ve talked with a lawyer.
  • Decide about the police on your own timeline. Whether and when to report is a deeply personal decision, and there’s no single right answer. If the assault happened at work, we believe it’s most effective to report it to both your employer and law enforcement, to help make sure it doesn’t happen again.

Checklist of what to save: the owner's video, photos of the scene, proof you were there and notes of what you remember

Talk to us about what happened

If you or someone you love was assaulted in a parking lot or garage in Texas, I’d like to hear what happened. I review every inquiry myself, and even when we can’t take a case, I often still point out what you’ll want to think about next. When we take a case on contingency, we earn a fee only if we win or settle it, so you don’t pay anything out of pocket. A consultation doesn’t make us your lawyers. That only happens if we both agree to work together. You can read more about how we handle sexual assault cases against property owners. We’re a female-led trial firm in Dallas, we meet by appointment only, and the consultation is free. Call us at (214) 390-4173 or set up a time to talk.

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Share on Vk
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
https://clgtrial.com/wp-content/uploads/article-parking-garage-level-warm-afternoon-light-scaled.jpg 1437 2560 Amy Carter https://clgtrial.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Carter-Law-Logo-Horizontal-.png Amy Carter2026-11-19 07:31:042026-11-19 07:31:04Assaulted in a Parking Lot or Garage? When You Can Sue for Negligent Security in Texas

Categories

  • Child Safety
  • Consumer Product Safety Commission
  • Current Litigation
  • Dangerous Products
  • Employment Discrimination
  • Food Safety Recalls
  • Hair Relaxer Cancer Lawsuit
  • Legal Process 101
  • Mental Health
  • Our Small Business Journey
  • Personal Injury
  • Product Recalls
  • Recalls from FDA
  • School Safety
  • Sexual Assault
  • Sexual Harassment
  • Silicosis
  • This Is Fine: A COO Story
  • Uncategorized

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • April 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • October 2025
  • September 2025
  • August 2025
  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • March 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • July 2024
  • April 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • October 2023
  • June 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • December 2021
  • October 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • May 2021
  • January 2021
  • February 2020
  • October 2019
Carter Law Group logo

A fierce, female-owned plaintiffs’ firm with over 20 years of experience taking on catastrophic injury, sexual assault, and workplace discrimination, and winning.

Contact Us

351 W Jefferson Blvd Ste. 503, Dallas, TX 75208

Amy Carter, Managing Shareholder

214.390.4173

Heather Davis, Partner

214.390.4173

Hon. Erin Nowell, Of Counsel

214.390.4173

Latest Posts

  • Empty upper level of a concrete parking garage in warm afternoon light
    Assaulted in a Parking Lot or Garage? When You Can Sue for Negligent Security in TexasNovember 19, 2026 - 7:31 am
  • Woman reading a document. Laptop, pen, and mug on her table.
    What to Do the Day You Get Fired in Texas (2026)October 20, 2026 - 7:23 am
  • Should You Hire a Lawyer to Negotiate Severance in Texas
    Should You Hire a Lawyer to Negotiate Severance in Texas? (2026)September 28, 2026 - 5:15 am
  • Why Won't a Lawyer Take My Employment Case Featured Image
    Why Won’t a Lawyer Take My Employment Case? What a No Really Means and What to Do NextSeptember 28, 2026 - 5:06 am
  • What to Do If You're Being Sexually Harassed at Work in Texas Featured Image
    What to Do If You’re Being Sexually Harassed at Work in TexasSeptember 28, 2026 - 5:00 am
© 2026 All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Awards | ADA Compliance
Link to: What to Do the Day You Get Fired in Texas (2026) Link to: What to Do the Day You Get Fired in Texas (2026) What to Do the Day You Get Fired in Texas (2026)Woman reading a document. Laptop, pen, and mug on her table.
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top